39 Allergy-Friendly Pie Shops

winston hero2

We’re celebrating Pi Day with our Allergy-Friendly Pie Shop Guide! Finding a safe pie is a slice of heaven and our guide features 39 of the sweetest spots to grab a slice, including 5 Spokin Verified Bakeries, dedicated allergen-free spots, and places that make finding a safe treat easy as pie. If you’ve found an allergy-friendly pie shop, please share a review on the Spokin App!

Image credit: Winston Pies

Arizona | California | Florida | Illinois | Kentucky | Maine | Maryland | Michigan | New York | Ohio | Pennsylvania | Texas | Wisconsin | Canada


app storeqr 1


Erin McKenna’s Bakery

Locations: New York, New York + Los Angeles, California + Santa Monica, California + Orlando, Florida

Types of Pie: Dutch Apple Pi Pie
Pies Free Of:
Top 9 (excluding coconut), Gluten
Bakery Dedicated Free Of: Milk, Egg, Soy Fish, Shellfish, Wheat, Gluten
Other Allergens They Can Accommodate:
Peanut, Tree Nut (excluding coconut)
Shipping: National

“Erin McKenna’s is dedicated gluten-free and vegan and this location has an entire sit-down brunch menu! Also, all their products are free from peanuts and tree nuts, but they don’t claim to be dedicated nut-free because they do bake with coconut. My boyfriend and I shared the pancakes with fresh berries and the apple pie waffles!”

@emsnutfreeeats, who manages peanut, tree nut, and celiac-gluten allergies

Karma Baker

Location: Westlake Village, California

Types of Pie: Apple Crumb, Pecan
Pies Free Of:
Milk, Egg, Soy, Fish, Shellfish, Wheat, Gluten, Sesame, Mustard, Animal Products, Honey, Gelatin
Bakery Dedicated Free Of: Milk, Egg, Fish, Shellfish, Wheat, Gluten, Sesame, Mustard, Animal Products, Honey, Gelatin

“A dedicated gluten-free and vegan dream! So many amazing goodies from donuts, cookies, cakes, cake pops, brownies, etc. They basically have it all!”

@eatglutenfreeaz, who manages milk, wheat, and celiac-gluten allergies

Two Fields Bakeshop

Location: Long Hill, New Jersey

Types of Pie: Apple Pie (GF and GF/DF options available)
Pies Free Of:
Peanut, Tree Nuts, Soy, Fish, Shellfish, Wheat, Gluten, Sesame, Oat, Legumes. GF/DF Apple Pie is also free of Milk.
Bakery Dedicated Free Of: Peanut, Tree Nuts, Fish, Shellfish, Wheat, Gluten, Sesame, Oat, Legumes
Other Allergens They Can Accommodate:
Milk, Egg, Soy, Sunflower
Shipping: National

“I had several of their baked goods shipped to me and every single one was incredible! It’s clear that they take pride in their baked goods and the quality was amazing.”

@emilybean, who manages a celiac-gluten allergy

The Difference Baker

Location: Ashburn, Virginia

Types of Pie: Chocolate Pudding, Chocolate, Cherry, Mixed Berry, and Blueberry
Pies Free Of:
Chocolate Pudding Pie is free of Peanut, Tree Nuts, Soy, Fish, Shellfish, Wheat, Gluten, Sesame, Corn, and Artificial Dyes. Chocolate Pie is Top 9 free. Cherry, Blueberry, and Mixed Berry Pies are free of Peanut, Tree Nuts, Milk, Soy, Fish, Shellfish, Wheat, Gluten, Sesame, Corn, and Artificial Dyes.
Bakery Dedicated Free Of: Peanut, Tree Nuts, Soy, Fish, Shellfish, Wheat, Gluten, Sesame, Corn, Artificial Dyes
Other Allergens They Can Accommodate:
Milk, Egg, Oat
Shipping: National

“I have become a huge fan of The Difference Baker! Living with celiac disease, it’s been a challenge to find a place that sells safe food. The Difference Baker is so great because it has such a wide selection of products to choose from, from meals, to bread, to desserts.”

@kk15, who manages wheat and celiac-gluten allergies

Mo’Pweeze Bakery

Location: Denville, New Jersey

Types of Pie: Personal Pies: Blueberry, Cherry, Dutch Apple, Pear Tart, Pumpkin, Sweet Potato and Large Pies: Blueberry, Cherry, Dutch Apple, Pumpkin, Sweet Potato, Raspberry
Pies Free Of:
Top 9, Gluten, Mustard
Bakery Dedicated Free Of: Top 9, Gluten, Mustard
Other Allergens They Can Accommodate:
Corn, Oat, Potato, Sunflower, Legumes, Rice

“This bakery is amazing! Being able to order something on the menu was something I hadn’t done in years!”

@blueeyedcj, who manages tree nut, soy, celiac-gluten, sesame, vegetable, and fruit allergies


Knead Luv Bakery Café

Location: Phoenix, Arizona

“Brand new 100% gluten-free bakery with organic gluten-free baked goods! They have bubble waffles, cinnamon rolls, pie, cupcakes, etc. They offer some dairy-free items as well!”

@eatglutenfreeaz, who manages milk, wheat, and celiac-gluten allergies


Winston Pies

Location: Los Angeles, California

“BEST vegan/gluten-free pies ever! You can get individual 5-inch pies that make the perfect pastry or breakfast. They have seasonal flavors and make most in a gluten-free and vegan option in a dedicated prep area. They always assure me that they are careful about contamination to completely avoid it. A must-have in LA.”

@gluttenous, who manages egg, wheat, grain, and celiac-gluten allergies


Location: Los Angeles, California

“Very allergy friendly if you do not have a nut allergy. They also offer kombucha floats, pie slices, and ice cream pints! All vegan!”

@jennatso8, who manages milk, egg, and meat allergies

The Pie Hole

Location: Pasadena, California

“Their peppermint pie was really delicious!”

@allykustera, who manages peanut and tree nut allergies

Lois the Pie Queen

Location: Oakland, California

“Safe for anaphylactic peanut allergies, but we stayed away from chocolate pies just in case.”

@pf100, who manages a peanut allergy


Tommy Bahamas

Location: Naples, Florida

“Wow. This spot has the BEST location with an outdoor restaurant—tables are in the sand! The perfect spot to watch the sunset. The food is really good, with very limited nuts. The staff is very educated on food allergies. We had deviled eggs with bacon (yum!), their famous pretzel bread, scallops, and apple pie. You HAVE to make a reservation!”

@susie, who manages peanut and tree nut allergies

The Turtle Club Restaurant

Location: Naples, Florida

“We had the ahi tuna tacos, coconut shrimp, and the rolls were safe for us. Also, they make their desserts in-house and my daughter was able to eat the key lime pie! She is NOT allergic to macadamia nuts—the crust is flour, butter, sugar and macadamia nuts.”

@susie, who manages peanut and tree nut allergies


Sally’s Gluten-Free Bakery

Location: Sandy Springs, Georgia

“Excellent bakery for gluten-free options. Cakes, bread, and pies. Dedicated gluten-free facility.”

@bmjacob, who manages a celiac-gluten allergy


First Slice Pie Cafe

Location: Chicago, Illinois

“All ingredients are listed under the pies and the pies are DELICIOUS!”

@awissink, who manages peanut, shellfish, fruit, and sesame allergies

Pie, Pie My Darling

Location: Chicago, Illinois

“Everything here is vegan so we did not have to worry about cross-contamination with milk or eggs, which are my daughter’s allergies. And the cake is beyond delicious. Hands down better than any non-vegan cake I’ve had.”

@scarmac, who manages milk and egg allergies

Sweet Mandy B’s

Location: Chicago, Illinois

“How have I not recommended this yet? Such a fantastic establishment! AMAZING sweets. Cakes, pies, cookies, and more. Their banana bread is so good too! And their frosting is amazing. It’s not allergy-free but I’ve been able to eat there for a decade with no problem.”

@natalie, who manages peanut and tree nut allergies

Defloured: A Gluten-Free Bakery

Location: Chicago, Illinois

“My extended family has multiple food allergies between us, so we were thrilled to find that this bakery makes allergy-free pies that can meet everyone’s needs at once! It’s now a tradition to order our pumpkin and apple pies from here, knowing they are gluten-free, nut-free, dairy-free, and soy-free.”

@stellzo, who manages peanut, tree nut, and fish allergies


Annie May’s Sweet Cafe

Location: Louisville, Kentucky

“Absolutely amazing. Best allergy bakery I’ve been to. I love the classic cupcake and the oatmeal cream pies, but always try to pick up something new. So many options for people with multiple food allergies.”

@foodallergygrl, who manages tree nut and egg allergies


Cake Cake Bakery

Location: Rockville, Maryland

“I brought their pie over for Thanksgiving dinner and it flew off the table (faster than the other really yummy non-sensitive pies/cakes. It was everyone’s favorite. They are a gluten-free, soy-free, nut-free and GMO-free bakery and their products can be purchased at Root Market or online via their webpage. Give them a try!”

@jasovi, who manages peanut, tree nut, and soy allergies


Salt Cod Cafe

Location: Harpswell, Maine

“So it turns out the owner of this little gem on Orrs Island has a niece who’s allergic to nuts so all the baked goods (and I believe all the food) are nut-free! Amazing pies, unbelievable scones, and muffins—all from scratch homemade! YUM”

@slasky, who manages tree nut, fruit, and legume allergies


Achatz Handmade Pie Co

Location: Chesterfield, Michigan

“Double-crust pies (blueberry, cherry, apple, 4 berries) are dairy-free and delicious! Sold at our local Whole Foods locations in Chicago and the suburbs. Some pies do contain dairy but the company has procedures in place to avoid cross-contamination.”

@amgaetano, who manages a milk allergy

Bake Station Too

Location: Farmington Hills, Michigan

“Completely nut and dairy-free bakery! Cupcakes, donuts, cookies, breads, birthday cakes, pies, pastries …a dream come true! My favorite bakery because I can pick ANYTHING off of the shelves!”

@alyssabauder, who manages a peanut allergy

Rumis Passion

Location: Plymouth, Michigan

“We love this bakery and the staff is soo friendly and helps answer our questions. Their focus is healthy, tasty, gluten-free bakery items from cakes to cookies and pies to bread to buns to pizza dough and muffins, and so much more. I do want to mention they are not a nut-free bakery. Everything is gluten-free and they do have several vegan options.”

@betsymarie, who manages a tree nut allergy



Location: Tuckahoe, New York

“I got a key lime pie from them at my farmer’s market and was thrilled! I also tasted the brownie which was very yummy. The vendor there, who seemed like the owner/chef, was very knowledgeable about allergies and his ingredients and assured me that his baked goods were safe. He said that they have a separate prep area for nut items and are very careful.”

@rs13, who manages peanut, tree nut, fish, shellfish, sesame, and legume allergies

Meredith’s Bread

Location: Kingston, New York

“This bakery has the tastiest gluten-free fresh loaf of bread I have ever had! It is hearty and has great texture whether toasted or not! So impressed by the fantastic selection of gluten-free breads, cookies, pies, muffins, and scones!”

@cbrauner, who manages a celiac-gluten allergy

Bagel Town

Location: West Hempstead, New York

“Just got my order from Bagel Town. Sesame and nut-free bakery! Apple pie, chocolate danishes, rugula, challah, bagel twists, “everything” bagels, whitefish salad, and coffee cake. And so reasonably priced! Delicious”

@staysafemom, who manages tree nut, seed, and legume allergies

Schuyler Bakery Inc

Location: Watervliet, New York

“My fiancée hasn’t ever had food from a bakery. I had my sister pick up a few pies over Christmas. They were absolutely delicious. Looking forward to buying all sorts of goodies soon!”

@joshhull97, who manages a peanut allergy

Red Barn Bakery

Location: Irvington, New York

“Amazing staff and helpful to people with celiac. They have gluten-free brownies, cakes, pies, and cupcakes. It is so delicious.”

@jeremyo, who manages tree nut, celiac-gluten, and sesame allergies


Mabel’s BBQ

Location: Cleveland, Ohio

“We had ribs, chicken wings, fried potatoes with vinegar and scallions, key lime pie, and it was all made safe for our allergens.”

@alohabailey, who manages peanut, tree nut, milk, egg, and sesame allergies

Kathy’s Creations

Location: Alliance, Ohio

“Kathy‘s baked goods are absolutely delicious! The prices are great too! I recommend her pizza rolls, rye bread, pies, and pizza crusts.”

@willow, who manages a celiac-gluten allergy



Location: Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania

“Trendy atmosphere and a conscientious staff! Waiters are briefed on allergy-friendly menu options/alterations and the chefs do their best to prevent contamination. They were even able to adjust their banana cream pie to be gluten-free for me and it was DIVINE! Highly recommend this spot for delicious food and flirty/fun atmosphere that feels like eating dinner in a big city.”

@gluttenous, who manages egg, wheat, celiac-gluten, and grain allergies

The Pie Place

Location: Pittsburg, Pennsylvania

“All of the pies here except those with a Dutch topping are dairy-free, as they use shortening instead. It’s nice to have somewhere easy to go where we can all share the same dessert.”

@punkinmama, who manages cashew and milk allergies


Pie Jacked

Location: Round Rock, Texas

“Top 8 allergen-free bakery in Round Rock (North of Austin). It was so cute and the owner was the sweetest! They are well-known for their pies and had the cutest mini ones in different fruit flavors and with fun designs! We also got some of their donuts (I really like the chocolate with powdered sugar) and a salted caramel cookie bar! Definitely worth the drive up if you’re staying in Austin!”

@emsnutfreeeats, who manages peanut, tree nut, wheat, and celiac-gluten allergies

Bob’s Steak & Chop House

Location: Dallas, Texas

“Bob’s handled my food allergies incredibly well! After I told the waiter about my allergies, he reminded me with each food item he brought to the table that it was safe to eat. He even had the chef specially prepare a key lime pie for me that was 100% nut-free! Great, safe place to eat.”

@nutfreemaddie, who manages peanut, tree nut, and sesame allergies


Elegant Farmer

Location: Mukwonago, Wisconsin

“World’s best apple pie. They told us that their standard, 8-inch apple pies are baked in their upstairs bakery and no other nuts are present upstairs. Be careful about everything else though.”

@cleanlabelmom, who manages peanut, tree nut, sesame, and legume allergies


Peaked Pies

Location: Whistler, British Colombia, Canada

“Their frozen pies are the first batch every morning, so they are most often safe.”

@elizabethgri, who manages tree nut, legume, and sesame allergies

The Cake Shop

Location: Ottawa, Ontario, Canada

“Nadine and her crew are amazing. We’ve even organized a cake decorating session with her and her team. Amazing cupcakes, donuts, cookies, pies, and more.”

@partrisc, who manages peanut, tree nut, fish, shellfish, sesame, carrot, and cherry allergies

Get the Spokin word in your inbox!
Be the first to get the latest updates and exclusive content sent to your email.