EAT
1. The Seafood Shanty
Location: Edgartown
“Had a safe meal here! Fries are fried separately, but do contain pea starch (not safe for me with my legume allergy). The manager brought out ingredients for me to check. A great experience and yummy food!”
@msmith228 who manages manages peanut, tree nut, egg, and legume allergies
2. Espresso Love
Location: Edgartown
“We love Expresso love. This cute coffee shop + more is a great place to stop while out shopping in downtown Edgartown. Many great smoothies, bagels and sandwiches. My peanut allergy child really loves the burgers here. Not to mention excellent coffee and matcha!!”
@ralphonse3 who manages a peanut allergy
3. Behind the Bookstore
Location: Edgartown
“Love the relaxed vibe of this cafe literally behind the bookstore. Great lunch options and coffees and teas. Bakery selections have tree nuts.”
@ralphonse3 who manages a peanut allergy
4. The Fish House
Location: Edgartown
“The carry out from this fresh fish house is worth the wait! We love the burgers and fries as well as the fresh fish options. The actual case options for at home preparation are among the freshest on the island including the marinated steak options which have proven safe and delicious for my peanut allergy child.”
@ralphonse3 who manages a peanut allergy
5. The Grey Barn and Farm
Location: Chilmark
“This place is incredible. There can often be tree nuts baked in the breads but we haven’t come across peanut. We love the fresh croissants and other breads on the weekends and so does our peanut allergy 8-year old. Great smoked fish and frozen beef options from their farm!”
@ralphonse3 who manages a peanut allergy
6. Edgartown Pizza
Location: Edgartown
“This place was awesome! We loved— we went there 3 times! Great place.”
@wavvpv manages tree nut allergies
7. Fat Ronnie’s Burger Bar
Location: Oak Bluffs
“This burger spot is awesome! Delicious burgers, great fries, and very nut-friendly. My peanut allergy child does a simple burger and fries here all the time! One of my island favs.”
@ralphonse3 who manages a peanut allergy
8. Nomans
Location: Oak Bluffs
“No peanuts in kitchen most times. Fun outdoor space for families to eat and appropriate space.”
@ralphonse3 who manages a peanut allergy
9. Black Sheep
Location: Edgartown
“This is a mainstay for our family. Though they can’t 100% guarantee some items we’ve had success with the beef tenderloin and chicken fingers from the extensive case of prepared foods. Additionally, so many great snacks and drinks.”
@ralphonse3 who manages a peanut allergy
10. Beach Road
Location: Tisbury
“Delicious, thoughtful fresh food. A more sophisticated menu and educated staff to walk through allergy concerns. Great for a night out or special dinner.”
@ralphonse3 who manages a peanut allergy
11. Alchemy Bistro & Bar
Location: Edgartown
“Such a wonderful vibe at this restaurant. Great food and educated staff. Take out is an option but you’ll want to sit and people watch. Not a lot of nuts on the menu but garnishes for some of the delicious salads may include tree nuts at times.”
@ralphonse3 who manages a peanut allergy
12. Nancy’s Restaurant
Location: Oak Bluffs
“Nancy’s is such an awesome find! The menu is extensive with so many great options for peanut allergy 8 year old. Location is the best-high energy and classic mv seafood!”
@ralphonse3 who manages a peanut allergy
13. Square Rigger Restaurant
Location: Edgartown
“We love the Square Rigger-the stuffed lobster is delicious. Tree nuts are on the menu on chicken salad but staff understand allergies and great with grilled items!”
@ralphonse3 who manages a peanut allergy
14. Rocco’s Pizzeria
Location: Tisbury
“Best pizza on the island. Thin crust, delicious and yes safe for my peanut allergy child! She even eats the delicious pastrami, burgers, chicken fingers and fries! Their take home and bake lasagnas and eggplant Parm is the real deal.”
@ralphonse3 who manages a peanut allergy
15. Waterside Market
Location: Tisbury
“Great lunch option in vineyard haven with a number of packaged items and and awesome grill. Creative sandwiches, fries and soups. Burgers and fries were safe option plus delicious teas and beverages. Don’t forget to check out the robes wines here!”
@ralphonse3 who manages a peanut allergy
16. Mocha Mott’s
Location: Oak Bluffs
“Great coffee and tea with decent bakery selection. Bagels were ok for peanut allergy child. Love going here to grab an iced coffee.”
@ralphonse3 who manages a peanut allergy
17. The Black Dog Tavern
Location: Vineyard Haven
“Loved this spot! They were great with food allergies!”
@susie who manages peanut and tree nut allergies
18. Giordano’s Restaurant
Location: Oak Bluffs
“We took our annual summer trip to Martha’s Vineyard and rediscovered this classic Italian gem. My peanut allergy 3 year old happens to love pizza and the team at Giordano’s keeps an up-to-date allergy list for their full menu. Much of which is peanut/nut-free! She had a slice for lunch every day with no issue. Can’t wait to head back.”
@ralphonse3 who manages a peanut allergy
TREAT
1. Ice Cream and Candy Bazaar
Location: Edgartown
“Staff was educated with a binder of all ice cream ingredients. She changed scoops and started a fresh tub for us!”
@carlyrugg who manages a peanut allergy
2. Pie Chicks
Location: Tisbury
“The best pies on the island with an educated group of bakers. Though you will find them in stores it’s best to order directly and ahead. Some pastries have tree nuts but pies and quiche are usually without. Pick up at the window and grab a cup of coffee.”
@ralphonse3 who manages a peanut allergy
3. Mad Martha’s Homemade Ice Cream
Location: Oak Bluffs
“They had a whole allergen notebook and had very clear allergy policies! Super educated and accommodating and I felt like I had a lot of options! My quickest and easiest experience at a new ice cream shop ever.”
@sophieschmults who manages tree nut and sesame allergies
